Best Actress Bracket Game: Katharine Hepburn Vs. Julie Andrews


If Julie Andrews looks a little concerned in the picture above, she has reason to be.  She’s facing off against the only four time Best Actress winner in Oscar history.  Going strictly by the numbers, Mary Poppins doesn’t stand a chance against Katharine Hepburn.  But she’s been known to have a little magic on her side.  Will a spoonful of sugar be enough?

But first, it’s time to check in on the results of yesterday’s match.


With God as her witness, Scarlett O’Hara will never be hungry again.  But she’s still done in this bracket game.  Swedish beauty Ingrid Bergman pumped Vivien Leigh out of the game with just over 75% of the votes.  That makes Bergman the first member of our final four where she will face the winner of today’s contest.

We’ve already established that Katharine Hepburn has twice as many Best Actress wins as anyone else in history.  But what’s mildly surprising is when she won the majority of her awards.  In the thirties and forties when Hepburn was arguably at her prime, she only took home one statue.  From 1942-1951, Hepburn experienced an Oscar drought during which she was not even nominated.

In the 50’s, after a boost from starring in The African Queen, Hepburn started getting nominated again.  But she wouldn’t win again until 1967 for Guess Who’s Coming to Dinner?  Once the floodgates were opened, Hepburn scored back-to-back wins with The Lion in Winter the following year.  Only one other actress can make that claim (Luise Rainer who won in 1936 and 1937).

While Hepburn stayed active through the 1970’s, the bulk of her work was on stage or television.  But she still managed to add to her numbers with one final win in 1981 for On Golden Pond.

Every so often, I am reminded of the wisdom of Daffy Stardust.  When he ran the Best Actor bracket game, he limited each contestant to a single performance.  This even the playing field.  I made the decision with this game to open things up, but there’s definitely a downside to doing so.  Readers have commented that based on numbers alone, Hepburn and Meryl Streep are very hard to beat.

If you’re basing your vote on stats, Hepburn’s wins and Streep’s nomination count are truly impressive.  Poor Julie Andrews has only one win and three nominations.  Hepburn wracked up more than that in just one decade.  If there’s an argument to be made for Andrews over Hepburn, it’s that her Oscar-winning performance has endured.  I suspect many readers here would rather revisit Mary Poppins than any of Hepburn’s four wins.  Her nomination for The Sound of Music just adds to her sentimental appeal.  And if you don’t like those goody-two-shoes movies, Andrews smashed her wholesome image in Victor Victoria.

Andrews may not have the numbers on her side.  But maybe she doesn’t need them.  It’s a long shot, but we’ve seen upsets in these games before…


Posted on February 15, 2017, in Awards, bracket game, Movies, Oscars and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.

  1. As far as body of work goes, it’s Hepburn. I just like Julie Andrews more.


  2. For me, it’s always Hepburn. Always always always. I can’t believe Bergman beat Leigh. I couldn’t stand it if Hepburn lost to Andrews, whom of course is a legend. To me, they’re just such different animals. But Hepburn played by her own rules which was unheard of in her day.

    Make me proud, fellow readers.


  3. As much as I love Julie, I do have to be in the right frame of mind to really want to sit down and watch a musical. On the other hand with Kate, she has The Lion in Winter, one of those perfect movies that demands to be watched. I will vote for Kate due to that movie alone.


  4. I love this contest, and it’s a good idea! But, if talking seriously, none of the actresses above are comparable with each other in that way…Diane Keaton vs Meryl Streep? Sounds like a joke!


  5. When voting, I haven’t concerned myself with the Oscar statistics, I’ve just gone on what films and performances one candidate vs. the other that I’ve enjoyed more. In that case, my vote here goes for Katharine Hepburn.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: