Fixing Oscar For One Film: Part Eight 2003-2016

Well, here we are in the final round of movies before we re-set for the championship group and we’ve expanded again to a window of fourteen years. Are certain eras of filmmaking measurably better than others? I have seen some opinions expressed that suggest while our current cinematic environment is producing an increased number of decent to good movies, that we’re seeing fewer truly great ones. In going over the various eras while working on this series, there does seem to have been some ebb and flow over the years and we might very well be in a mild leveling-off period when it comes to actual brilliance. It might also be the case that the films of the last fifteen years haven’t had the time to solidify into classics in our minds.

However you feel about it, the following films certainly qualify as some of the best or most memorable Best Picture nominees to not come out on top on the night of the ceremony.

Lost In Translation (2003)

We pretty much went into 2003 knowing that as long as Peter Jackson and company didn’t wet the bed in the final installment of their enormously successful and critically lauded Lord of the Rings series, that they were in line for a heaping pile of awards. Although the first installment is still the most satisfying from my point of view, I’m not going to argue that Return of the King was an undeserving winner, just that it’s too bad a perfect little gem of a movie like Lost In Translation never really stood a chance. In retrospect, director Sofia Coppola’s big breakout movie wasn’t just left wanting in the categories it was nominated in, but maybe should have had additional nominations in both cinematography and film editing. As with plenty of other Best Picture losers over the years like Citizen Kane, Her, Fargo, and Pulp Fiction, the Best Original Screenplay award was perhaps used as a consolation prize of sorts because the Academy knew that Lost In Translation wasn’t likely to grab the other big prizes it was in line for. This same approach may just be in the offing this year as a way of calling attention to a film such as Lady Bird or Get Out.

Oscar Nominations: Best Picture, Director, Actor
Oscar Wins: Best Original Screenplay

The Social Network (2010)

Here’s a case where I may be guilty in either falling in line with preferring a traditional “Oscar-style” film or perhaps merely valuing subject matter that is very close to my own heart. Perhaps for partly these reasons I have continued to believe over the intervening years that Tom Hooper’s film about King George VI’s struggle with poor speech fluency at a time when his ability to speak confidently and comfortingly to his subjects was of the greatest importance was indeed the right choice as the Best Picture of 2010. I’m not going to rescind that opinion, but I will say that this might have been one of those situations in which the Best Director award should have been split from the Academy’s choice for Best Picture. It would have been perfectly appropriate in this case to award the consistently excellent David Fincher, who may have been done in by a split in votes with other more modern approach directors like Darren Aronofsky and David O Russell. The Social Network is certainly a more than worthy subject for film study, especially for its Oscar-winning adapted screenplay and its typically sharp cinematography and editing. Consider it here to move on to our championship round.

Oscar Nominations: Best Picture, Director, Actor, Sound Mixing, Cinematography
Oscar Wins: Best Adapted Screenplay, Original Score, Film Editing

Gravity (2013)

In the age of both amazing advances in special effects in film and increased use of home theater strategies for consuming movie offerings, it is perfectly understandable why the Academy might be wary of throwing the Best Picture award in the direction of a film whose strengths are most notably in its visuals and other technical domains. Such an approach will have inconsistent long term results, though. As the years go on and film fans continue to experience these movies at home with a wide variety of available hardware their mileage may vary. This game concern may be part of why this year’s amazing theater experience of cinematography and sound Dunkirk has receded after opening to big awards conjecture. I remember getting glowing reports back on Gravity from friends who had seen it on the big screen before I had a chance, and their enthusiasm for the experience they had in that context was not misplaced. What I walked out of the movie theater sensing, however, was echoed by the Academy when Gravity failed to garner a nomination in either of the screenplay categories. As impressive as the technical achievements of Gravity were, when it comes down to it, if you don’t have many votes from the writers or from the actors who both make up the largest portion of the voting population and who have to speak the given lines and play the given parts, your chances of winning Best Picture go way down.

Oscar Nominations: Best Picture, Actress, Production Design
Oscar Wins: Best Director, Original Score, Sound Editing, Sound Mixing, Cinematography, Film Editing, Visual Effects

Mad Max: Fury Road (2015)

You can pretty much take everything I just said about Gravity above and apply it to Mad Max: Fury Road in 2015. Although I will say that the newest Mad Max film has both stuck with me stronger to this date and that I didn’t notice how thin its overall plot was until I saw it a second time. Multiple screenings of George Miller’s amazing work, however, has only strengthened my admiration of the absolute virtuosity of the filmmaking involved in telling that thin story. Mad Max: Fury Road should become the subject of intense study at film schools across the world because of its masterful use of visual storytelling, camera placement, and the writing that had nothing to do with what the characters were saying. What becomes obvious is how painstakingly arduous and well-conceived the story boarding on this movie was. Black Panther‘s Ryan Coogler and company could take some lessons from Miller and his team of filmmakers. While I do think the script is undervalued to some degree, this is an example of how the Academy repeatedly undervalues science fiction and fantasy pictures when it comes time for the ‘above-the-line’ categories on Oscars night, so much so that nobody ever really considered this to be a viable Best Picture winner. Again, I’m not going to argue that this nominee should have beaten out the eventual winner (Spotlight was, after all, my very favorite movie of that year for entirely opposite reasons), but I’d give it a pretty strong recommendation to our voters here.

Oscar Nominations: Best Picture, Director, Cinematography, Visual Effects
Oscar Wins: Best Film Editing, Sound Editing, Sound Mixing, Costume Design, Makeup and Hairstyling, Production Design

La La Land (2016)

Oh boy is this a divisive movie! If you were reading here last year you know that I went back to the movie theater for a second look at La La Land to confirm what my initial misgivings had been about the movie and why I had come out of the theater loving it nonetheless. In the end, I gave La La Land a less than enthusiastic endorsement for the Best Picture win, in part because none of the other nominated films had been particularly faultless either and it was the movie that I suspected I’d watch most often in the future for its mixture of design and emotion and appealing froth. It seemed like a Best Picture winner, too. I guess I understand why so many of the Academy voters fell for Moonlight with its beautiful cinematography, strong performances, and meaningful social topicality, but for whatever reason I found myself one step ahead of it and mostly emotionally at bay over the course of its run time. Moonlight‘s win has been largely attributed to the new preferential ballot and its relative high position on many ballots in comparison to La La Land‘s tendency to show up either very high or very low on ballots, picking up fewer votes as the tallying process progressed. I’m looking forward to seeing how our voters place it among this group of competitors.

Oscar Nominations: Best Picture, Actor, Original Screenplay, Sound Editing, Sound Mixing, Costume Design, Film Editing
Oscar Wins: Best Director, Actress, Original Score, Original Song, Production Design, Cinematography

These movies are much more recent in our memories, so maybe we have more immediate reactions to them or maybe we’re more or less invested in their Oscars night fates. Let us know where you stand both by voting here and telling us how you feel about them in the comments section.


Posted on February 28, 2018, in Awards, Movies, Oscars, poll and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 11 Comments.

  1. Just because it still makes me mad that the makers of LA LA LAND were so cruelly given the prize and had it taken away – I vote for LA LA LAND.


  2. This is, I think, the weakest batch of the bunch. It came down to Lost in Translation and Mad Max for me. Mad Max is as close to a perfectly executed action movie as I think exists, so it got my vote.


    • I’m curious if anybody has any other movies that fit within this time period that they would have included instead of these. I personally love the movie Her, but beyond a screenplay win the movie didn’t have enormous buzz and didn’t do great box office business so I figured that would be a case of me just putting one of my personal favorites in. These looked like some of the more popular nominees I put my eyes on, but I’m curious if there would have been some other suggestions.


    • I went with Mad Max for similar reasons.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. When I first starting reading through the entries here, I thought it was going to be tough. Then I looked at the voting board and realized it was not difficult at all. First I had to separate out strong negative emotion and the resultant feeling of having to compensate. I have a deep, seething hatred for The Social Network. But did that mean I had to vote for it because so many people like it? Answer: No.
    Gravity was an impressive project and the lead performances just killed me. I’d have to say it’s Bullock’s finest. It’s also a one and done – which eliminates it from contention. Never saw Fury Road. So it’s between Lost in Translation and La La Land – both such delicious projects, both with such strong emotional impact. I could watch either of these numerous times. It’s not quite a flip of the coin though – voted La La Land. It comes down to the difference between musing to oneself in the subsequent days about an interesting movie, and between having your entire being consumed with the emotional aftermath. I hope I never get that emotionally invested in an Oscar race ever again.


  4. I would also submit “Bridge of Spies” is among the greats. Best Picture, Best Director, and yes Best Actor. I think Spielberg and Hanks just made it look too easy. Have only seen it three times but looking forward to more.


  5. The author’s lack of enthusiasm for this bunch is apparent. I’ve seen two of these.

    Fury Road is a great action flick, but best movie of the year? Eh…

    How one feels about The Social Network depends in large part on how true to actual events you believe a historical drama should be. As a fictional work about a dot-com startup, it is compelling. As for its accuracy, however, I am convinced by the critiques that its depiction of Mark Zuckerberg, as an autistic nerd seething with envy and resentment about Harvard final clubs and row crew jocks and WASP exclusion, has more to do with the screenwriter’s own hang-ups than the real Zuckerberg.

    USA Today also has an article on a similar theme:


  6. I would have added “Sideways”, along with “Brokeback Mountain” on here. Two of my personal favorites of this time period.

    I didn’t get to vote, but I am torn between “La La Land” and “Lost in Translation”. I think I would go with the latter, for being such a dream state film of disorientation in a different world. But it’s close. “La La Land” was so fun!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: